Book Review – Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card

“All right. We’re saving the world, after all. Take him.”

Though I’ve tried my best not to, this review may spoil some things. Reader be warned!

Like the middle bear of Goldilocks fame, Ender is a culmination of the “just right.” He’s the youngest of three genetically engineered Wiggin children. The oldest, Peter Wiggin, is cold-blooded but lacks control. Valentine, the middle child and only girl, is calculating but lacks callousness. Ender is the one the human race has been waiting for. The one who will lead them to victory in the third and final battle against the hostile alien “Buggers.”

So they hope. First, he must be vetted and trained.

We follow him from schoolyard to space station as he engages in a series of military games against A.I. and other gifted children. Friends and enemies all do their part to complete Ender, shaping him into a person that must rely on his own wits and intellect in order to survive.

I really think this book deserves its praise. The writing is engaging and I felt an enormous amount of sympathy toward Ender. I know there are follow-up books set in the same universe, but because I feel this one stands so strongly on its own, I’m unsure whether or not I’ll read them.

While perusing reviews, I’ve come across some common criticisms that I’d like to address:

  • Ender isn’t interesting because he never really fails.

This line of thought holds some truth. After the first few chapters, I never really expected him to come up short against any of the obstacles tossed his way. Sure, he feels that he’s failed at some points, believing he’s becoming the brother he despises.

But I never felt bored with him. In my opinion, the lack of try-fail cycles isn’t critical because the climax is a spectacular failure, one which he hopes to make up for at the end.

  • Ender doesn’t act his age.

Based on his level of intelligence, a lot of people have a hard time believing Ender is so young. I felt the same through most of the book. But afterward, I reflected on the futuristic setting coupled with genetic engineering, and decided there was enough plausibility for me to buy into it.

I also think we have a tendency to forget just how intelligent we all were at his age. We may not have been able to express ourselves due to lack of life experience, but I can recall having “complex” thoughts that might seem unusual for a six-year-old.

I must say, I’ve been enjoying my last couple of “science fiction classic” reads. I’ll be taking a break to read some non-fiction for NaNoWriMo inspiration, but I look forward to the next one.

If you haven’t sat down with Ender’s Game, I’d say grab a copy.

-Phillip

0 thoughts on “Book Review – Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card

  1. I love love LOVED this book. Looking forward to the film…

    1. Agree Aussa, definitely looking forward to it now!

  2. Hmmm. I’m not sure I agree, at least not yet. I’m reading it aloud to my kids in the evening, and I sometimes find the writing vague and confusing. For example, the author has not explained what the heck a Bugger is! I’m going on the general assumption that Buggers are the bad guys, but it would be nice to have a clear cut explanation. My ten-year-old keeps saying “This book is so confusing! I don’t know what’s going on!” We’re only in the 7th chapter, so we’ll continue to press on. For now. Nice to hear your opinion, Phillip. I’m staying hopeful that we’ll like this book.

    1. You make a great point, Gwen. The writing can definitely be vague and confusing at times. It seems to have what I call a ‘hard literary sci-fi’ feel to it where the ambiguity is sometimes intentional. Not everyone’s cup of tea, and honestly, not often mine either. I’m not sure why this book is marketed toward the younger folks, because I think if I was a kid reading it, I would have given up early on. Good luck with your continued reading and I look forward to hearing your thoughts when/if you’ve finished.

  3. By the way, love the new look on the blog. Nice to change things up once in a while, isn’t it?

    1. Thank you! I was bit by some bug to change things around, so it’s still a work in progress. But I really like the template I found.

  4. Love the new look!
    Great review. I read Ender’s Game years ago. Like you, I can understand the criticisms. But the didn’t bother me as I read the book. And I see that in the movie version, they aged him a bit. I’m a bit nervous about the film though the trailer looks great. Whenever I really like a book, I’m always wary of what filmmakers will do to it. Having been burned before (Earthsea; Lightning Thief), I can’t help being skeptical.

    1. Thanks Marie! I’ve been wasting time messing around with my layout when I should have been working on my NaNoWriMo outline… oh well.

      I agree with you about the film. I often regret reading something before seeing the movie, because as you mentioned, getting burned happens more often than not. I imagine that at least the SFX will be worth it though.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.